How To Negotiate With Frost Arnett Debt Collector: A Complete Guide

by Joe Mahlow • Updated on Jul. 17, 2025

A caption for the above image.

Quick Answer: How to Negotiate With Frost Arnett

To negotiate with Frost Arnett, first validate the debt in writing within 30 days of contact. Then, review for errors or inflated charges. Once confirmed, offer a low initial settlement or ask for a payment plan based on your budget. Always get the agreement in writing and never admit to the debt before validation. Know your rights under the FDCPA, and don’t hesitate to seek help from a credit pro if needed.

Is your phone buzzing with calls from Frost Arnett demanding payment for medical debt?

Are you unsure whether this company is legitimate or just another scam trying to intimidate you into paying?

Have you noticed that the debt amount seems inflated, or you're wondering if there's a way to reduce what you owe?

Talking about collections, did you know that medical debt collections have become increasingly aggressive in recent years?

As healthcare costs rise and insurance gaps widen, more Americans are finding unpaid medical bills sent to collections faster than ever. In fact, a study by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) revealed that medical collections make up the majority of collection tradelines on credit reports.

And the kicker is many of these debts are surprise charges or billing errors that consumers never even knew they owed.

In this guide, you'll learn proven tactics for negotiating with Frost Arnett.

Let’s understand your legal protection.

Finally, discover how to resolve your debt on terms that work for your financial situation.

Frost Arnett: What You Need to Know First

Before we talk about negotiation strategies, let's establish the facts about who you're dealing with.

Frost Arnett is a legitimate debt collection agency based in Nashville, Tennessee, with over a century of experience in healthcare revenue cycle management. Founded in 1893, the company specializes in collecting medical debt for healthcare providers, making them one of the most established players in medical debt collection.

Unlike scam operations that flood the market, Frost Arnett operates under strict federal regulations and maintains proper licensing.

They provide various services including early insurance follow-ups, pre-service financial clearance, and bad debt collections specifically for healthcare organizations.

Who does Frost-Arnett Collect For?

Frost-Arnett is focused exclusively on medical-related debts. They are hired by healthcare providers or purchase unpaid balances to collect on their behalf.

Here's a breakdown based on official information and independent sources:

Hospitals
Clinics and Doctor’s Offices
Radiology and Imaging Centers (e.g., Columbus Radiology, Digestive Health Management, Premiere Radiology)
Labs, Surgery Centers, and other medical facilities

According to Frost-Arnett’s own FAQ, they collect “on behalf of healthcare providers” and specialize in resolving patient-pay balances.

Is Frost Arnett Debt Collection Legitimate?

Short answer: Yes. Frost-Arnett is a real, legitimate debt collection company.

But here’s where things get a little messy…

Some consumers online have called Frost-Arnett a “scam.”

Why?

Not necessarily because of how the company operates, but because scammers have been impersonating them.

This tactic is known as spoofing, when hackers pretend to be a real company (like Frost-Arnett) to trick people into giving up sensitive personal or financial information.

They're not actually affiliated with Frost-Arnett, but they use similar phone numbers, fake emails, or even real-looking letters to appear legitimate.

Here’s what some people have said online:

“They claimed I owed a medical bill, but I had never been to that hospital. When I asked for proof, they got aggressive and hung up. Total scam vibes.”
— Reddit user, r/personalfinance
“The number said it was Frost Arnett, but it felt off. They couldn’t tell me the original creditor. I called the real Frost-Arnett and they had no record of me.”
— Consumer complaint via online forum

So if you get a call or letter from “Frost-Arnett,” don’t panic, but do your due diligence. Verify the debt. Ask for it in writing. And never give out personal info unless you’re sure it’s the real deal.

Pro tip: Always contact the company directly using the number listed on their official website, not the one that called or texted you.

Why This Matters for Your Frost Arnett Negotiation Strategy

When Frost Arnett contacts you, they're typically collecting on behalf of a hospital, clinic, or medical practice where you received treatment. This means they're acting as a third-party collector, which affects both your rights and negotiation leverage.

Medical debt collectors like Frost Arnett often purchase debts from healthcare providers at steep discounts , sometimes as low as 5-15 cents on the dollar.

This creates significant room for negotiation that many consumers don't realize exists.

Verify the Debt Before Any Negotiation

Pay close attention to this crucial first step, it can save you thousands of dollars.

Under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), you have the right to request debt validation within 30 days of first contact. This isn't optional; it's a strategic move that protects you from paying debts that aren't yours or contain errors.

What to Request in Your Validation Letter

Send a written request to Frost Arnett asking for:

The original creditor's name and address
The exact amount of the debt
Documentation proving the debt is yours
Proof that Frost Arnett has the right to collect this debt
An itemized breakdown of the charges

Mail this request via certified mail with a return receipt requested.

So what happens next? Frost Arnett must stop collection efforts until they provide this validation.

Common Issues That Surface During Validation

Approximately 80% of medical bills contain errors, making validation crucial. Common problems include:

Billing errors and duplicate charges
Insurance processing problems
Services you never received
Incorrect patient information
Charges already paid through insurance

If Frost Arnett cannot provide adequate proof, you may be able to dispute the debt entirely.

Know Your Rights: The Legal Foundation for Negotiation

Next, remember your legal protections, these form the backbone of your negotiating position.

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act provides significant protections when dealing with collectors like Frost Arnett. Understanding these rights strengthens your negotiating position and protects you from abusive practices.

What Frost Arnett Cannot Do

Contact you at work if you've told them it's not allowed
Call before 8 AM or after 9 PM
Discuss your debt with family, friends, or coworkers
Use profanity, threats, or intimidation
Misrepresent the amount owed or their authority
Threaten legal action they don't intend to take

Your Rights During Collection

You have the right to:

Request all communication in writing
Dispute the debt within 30 days
Ask them to stop calling (they must comply)
Seek damages if they violate the FDCPA

Violations of these rules can result in damages up to $1,000 plus attorney fees. Document any inappropriate behavior, it provides powerful leverage in negotiations.

Before We Talk About Negotiation Tactics, Assess Your Financial Position

Your negotiation strategy depends entirely on your financial reality. Take time to create a realistic budget showing your income, essential expenses, and available funds for debt payment.

This information serves two purposes:

It helps you determine what you can genuinely afford
It prevents you from agreeing to unrealistic payment terms

Consider both one-time settlement offers and monthly payment plans. Generally, lump-sum settlements achieve better results, but monthly payments may be more manageable for your budget.

Effective Negotiation Strategies That Work

Strategy 1: Start Low and Negotiate Up

When negotiating a settlement, start with an offer significantly lower than what you're willing to pay. If the debt is $5,000, you might start by offering $1,000. This gives you room to negotiate while potentially achieving a better outcome than expected.

Remember that Frost Arnett likely purchased this debt for a fraction of its face value. Even a 20-30% settlement represents profit for them in many cases.

How Much Should I Settle?

Here’s a visual chart showing recommended settlement offer amounts for a $5,000 debt.

Starting at 20–30% ($1,000–$1,500) gives you strong negotiation room. Collectors like Frost Arnett often accept these lower offers because they still turn a profit on purchased debt.

Strategy 2: Leverage Hardship Circumstances

If you're facing financial hardship due to unemployment, medical issues, or other circumstances, explain this to Frost Arnett. Many collectors have hardship programs that offer reduced payments or extended payment terms.

Be prepared to provide documentation of your hardship, such as:

Unemployment benefits statements
Medical bills showing ongoing treatment
Proof of reduced income
Disability documentation

Strategy 3: Negotiate Favorable Payment Terms

If you cannot pay a lump sum, focus on negotiating favorable payment terms:

Request the lowest possible monthly payment
Ask for interest-free payment plans
Try to limit the payment period to avoid long-term obligations
Get agreements that payments won't increase over time

Strategy 4: Request Written Confirmation

Never agree to payment arrangements verbally. Request written confirmation of any agreement before making payments. This documentation should include:

The settlement amount or payment terms
Payment due dates
Confirmation that the agreement satisfies the debt completely
Agreement that the account will be reported as "paid" or "settled" to credit bureaus

What to Expect During Negotiation Calls

Before we talk about what to avoid, understand what Frost Arnett representatives are trained to do.

They're skilled negotiators who may use various tactics to encourage full payment. They might:

Emphasize the impact on your credit score
Suggest that settling will look bad on your credit report
Claim their offer is "final" when it isn't
Create urgency by mentioning potential legal action

Stay calm and remember that negotiation is expected in debt collection. Most initial offers are not final, and collectors have authority to accept reduced payments.

If you feel pressured, don't hesitate to ask for time to consider their offer. You can also request to speak with a supervisor who may have more authority to approve favorable terms.

Critical Mistakes That Can Destroy Your Negotiation

Pay close attention to these common mistakes that can undermine your negotiation efforts:

Don't admit the debt is yours during initial conversations. Instead, request validation first.
Don't give access to your bank account for automatic payments until you have a written agreement.
Don't agree to payment amounts you cannot afford just to end the conversation.
Don't ignore the collector hoping they'll disappear. This often leads to legal action.
Don't negotiate with incomplete information about your rights or the debt's validity.

Understanding the Consequences of Failed Negotiations

If negotiations fail, Frost Arnett may pursue legal remedies. They can:

File a lawsuit against you
Obtain a court judgment
Garnish your wages (in states where allowed)
Freeze bank accounts
Place liens on property

However, legal action is expensive and time-consuming. Most collectors prefer negotiated settlements, especially for smaller amounts.

If you're served with a lawsuit, don't ignore the court papers. Respond by the deadline and consider consulting with a professional who specializes in debt collection defense.

collection accounts hurting your credit score

When Professional Help Becomes Necessary

Before we talk about credit implications, consider seeking professional help if:

The debt amount is substantial (over $10,000)
You're facing multiple collection actions
Frost Arnett violates your rights under the FDCPA
You believe the debt is not yours or contains errors
You're considering bankruptcy

Many attorneys offer free consultations for debt collection cases, and some work on contingency if the collector has violated federal law.

How Different Outcomes Affect Your Credit Score

While negotiating, consider how different outcomes affect your credit score:

Paid settlements typically have less negative impact than unpaid collections
Payment plans show ongoing responsibility
Negotiating "pay for delete" (removal from credit reports) provides the best outcome but is less common

Request that Frost Arnett report the account as "paid as agreed" rather than "settled" if possible, though this may require paying the full amount.

Advanced Negotiation Tactics for Better Results

The Documentation Strategy

Request detailed documentation of all charges before negotiating. Often, reviewing itemized bills reveals errors or charges that can be disputed, reducing the overall debt amount.

The Timing Advantage

Negotiate near the end of the month or quarter when collectors may be more motivated to close deals to meet quotas.

The Multiple Contact Strategy

If one representative won't budge, politely end the call and try again with a different representative. Different collectors may have different levels of authority or motivation.

2025 Update: How Recent Changes Affect Medical Debt Collection

Recent regulatory changes have made medical debt collection more consumer-friendly:

Credit reporting agencies now wait longer before reporting medical debt
Certain medical debts under $500 are no longer reported to credit bureaus
Healthcare providers face new requirements for patient financial assistance programs

Use these changes to your advantage during negotiations. Mention recent regulatory protections and ask about financial assistance programs from the original healthcare provider.

Creating a Negotiation Timeline

Week 1: Send debt validation request and gather documentation

Week 2-3: Review validation response and identify discrepancies

Week 4: Begin negotiation with initial settlement offer

Week 5-6: Negotiate terms and request written agreement

Week 7: Finalize agreement and make payment

This timeline allows for thorough preparation while maintaining momentum in negotiations.

Final Recommendations: Turning Frost Arnett Debt Collection into Resolution

Successfully negotiating with Frost Arnett requires preparation, patience, and persistence. The key is understanding that both parties benefit from reasonable resolution, Frost Arnett gets paid, and you resolve the debt without prolonged stress.

Remember these essential points:

Verify the debt before negotiating
Understand your legal rights
Document all communications
Get agreements in writing
Don't hesitate to seek professional help when needed

With the right approach, you can resolve your medical debt on terms that work for your financial situation while protecting your rights throughout the process. The goal isn't just to end collection calls, it's to achieve a fair resolution that allows you to move forward financially.

Medical debt collection doesn't have to be overwhelming. Armed with knowledge about your rights, strategic negotiation tactics, and a clear understanding of the process, you can work on this challenge successfully. Cheers to a resolution that serves your best interests!

More Debt Collection Stories:

Disclaimer: This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or credit advice. We are not affiliated with Frost-Arnett or any collection agency. Always consult with a credit professional for guidance specific to your situation.